DPG is a comprehensive underwater photography website and community for underwater photographers. Learn underwater photography techniques for popular digital cameras and specialized professional underwater equipment (wide angle, macro, super macro, lighting and work flow). Read latest news, explore travel destinations for underwater photography. Galleries of professional and amateur underwater photography including wrecks, coral reefs, undersea creatures, fashion and surfing photography.
Dive Photo Guide

News

Nigel Barker Shoots The Seal Hunt For The Humane Society
By Jason Heller, August 4, 2008 @ 02:00 AM (EST)

In the wake of environmental decline and man's impact on the earth, and the ocean, there are several marine mammal hunts, including international whaling, and the dolphin slaughter in Japan, that are simply unsustainable, not to mention inhumane. Canada's annual commercial seal hunt has become the single largest commercial hunt of marine mammals on the planet. The Canadian government and fishing industry continue to support the hunt under false pretenses and in recent years the Humane Society has stepped in  to document the activities and to create awareness of the basic facts about the hunt.

The Canadian government has been trying to tone down the negative media coverage and global pressure against the hunt the last few years. This year they even tried to enforce a "no filming or documenting the hunt" policy.

This year the Humane Society recruited Nigel Barker, a major fashion photographer and most recently a judge on America's Next Top Model, to help document the beauty of these seals, whose furs would otherwise end up selling to the fashion industry itself.

 


 

Nigel brought a crew and his equipment, including medium format cameras, strobes and power packs, to the Canadian Arctic, to shoot the hunt.  For 2008 the Canadian Fisheries department set the quota at 275,000 seals to be killed. Although he did witness some of the horrors of the hunt, his images were to be used to document the beauty of these animals, not the cruelty and greed of man.

We were invited to the gallery opening for "A Sealed Fate?" on July 24th in New York at 401 Projects gallery, a fairly new art gallery in the hip area of the "west village" (West Greenwich Village for those of you not from NYC). Apparently 401 Projects is specifically used for cause related artwork and photography exhibits. It's a very cool spot. Over 800 guests, including many celebrities, turned out for the opening.

 


Pat Reagan (HSUS), Nigel Barker, Wendy Heller, John Grandy (HSUS), Cristen Chin (Nigel's wife)

 

According to the Humane Society, the Canadian Department of Fisheries have made the following statement:

"The landed value of seals was $16 million in 2004. Pelt prices as high as $70 have recently been recorded. Seals are a significant source of income for some individual sealers. The money is earned over a very short period. Sealing also creates employment opportunities for buying and processing plants." 

The Humane Society continues to uncover some facts of the sealing industry:

"The seal hunt provides very low economic returns for Canada, Newfoundland and individual sealers. In light of the negative impact the seal hunt has on Canada's international reputation, its continuation cannot be justified on economic grounds.

Even in Newfoundland, where more than 90% of sealers live, revenues from sealing account for less than 1% of the Gross Domestic Product and less than 3% of the landed value of the fishery. Even northern cod, considered by many to be commercially extinct, makes up 8% of the landed value of Newfoundland’s fishery today.

Sealing is an off-season activity conducted by a few thousand fishermen from Canada’s east coast. The Newfoundland government itself estimates there are only 4,000 active sealers in any given year. Media reports and government data confirm they make, on average, less than 5% of their incomes from sealing, and the rest from commercial fisheries.

Any profits from the seal hunt are offset by the large government subsidies that continue to be provided to the sealing industry. Moreover, vessel owners must cover the cost of repairs to their boats, which are often damaged by heavy ice at the seal hunt (insurance companies impose a high deductible for vessels participating in the hunt)."

Sealing is also practiced by the native Inuit People, and dates back throughout their history. This is a sustainable, sustenance driven practice and very different from what the world has come to know as the "Canadian Seal Hunt". The Humane Society has been documenting the seal hunt and issues relating to the hunt, the facts and the myths for several years now.

"The commercial seal hunt is wasteful—seals are taken for their fur, and their carcasses are almost always left to rot on the ice. The Canadian government deliberately tries to blur the lines between the commercial seal hunt, which is conducted by non-native people off Canada's east coast, and subsistence hunting by Inuit people in Canada's arctic region. But animal protection groups, including The HSUS, are not opposed to Inuit subsistence hunting. Canada’s commercial seal hunt is an industrial-scale slaughter conducted by fishermen from Canada’s east coast. The seals are killed for their skins, which are sold in overseas fashion markets. The carcasses are almost always left to rot on the ice because there are virtually no markets for the meat.

Each year, video footage of the hunt shows stockpiles of carcasses left across the ice floes and sealers dumping carcasses over the sides of their boats. DFO inspectors have acknowledged the large number of carcasses left to rot on the ice in internal documents. Moreover, despite claims to the contrary by the Government of Canada, Canadian international trade data clearly shows that Canada has not exported even one dollar’s worth of seal meat at any point in the last 5 years.

Claims that seal oil markets have grown substantially in recent years are also untrue. Seal oil is a byproduct of the skin trade (blubber is attached to the skins when they are removed from the seals). Canadian international trade data shows that Canadian exports of marine mammal oil in 2004 were valued at just about half of what they were in 2000 It is impossible to characterize this as "substantial growth."

Make no mistake, sealers kill seals for their skins—there is no trade in seal meat and trade in seal oil is brings in very little additional income."

Lastly, as it relates to the inhumane mathods used and condoned by the Canadian Fisheries Department, which claims:

"Hunting methods were studied by the Royal Commission on Sealing in Canada and they found that the clubbing of seals, when properly performed, is at least as humane as, and often more humane than, the killing methods used in commercial slaughterhouses, which are accepted by the majority of the public."

While in actuality, the Humane Society rebuts based on facts that this method is cruel and unacceptable. They have documented inhumane methods that must stop:

"The Canadian commercial seal hunt involves a level of cruelty that no thinking, compassionate person would tolerate if they could see it for themselves.

While cruelty may exist in other wildlife hunts and in domestic animal slaughters, this does not change the irrefutable fact that Canada’s commercial seal hunt results in considerable, unacceptable, and needless suffering. Veterinary studies, video evidence and eye-witness testimony by independent journalists, scientists and parliamentarians confirms that seals are often skinned alive, that conscious seal pups are routinely hooked with metal spikes and dragged across the ice, that injured seals are often thrown into stockpiles and left to suffocate in their own blood, that seals are shot and left to suffer in agony, and that wounded seals often slip beneath the surface of the water where they bleed to death slowly and are never recovered. This is a level of cruelty to animals that Canadians find unacceptableespecially given it occurs to produce frivolous fashion items."


More information on the seal hunt can be found at the links below:

Sea Shepherd

Humane Society

Canadian Seal Hunt

RELATED ARTICLES

RELATED PRODUCTS

Fantasea FG7X II
Ikelite Housing for Nikon D500
I-DiveSite Venom 35s
SeaLife DC2000
John Natoli
Aug 21, 2008 5:43 AM
John Natoli wrote:
I really can't understand how this can continue to happen - the slaughter of these animals is pointless but more importantly, totally inhumane. I recently had the pleasure to dive with Australian Sea Lions as well as spend some time, approx 4 hrs, with New Zealand fur seals on a land base excursion. These animals are fascinating. Their inquisitive nature almost gives them a human like quality. One look into a seals eyes and you gain a sense of emotional connection that is not experienced with other animals. Once this heartfelt connection is made, it is impossible to see how there is any justification for the senseless slaughter of these animals ... it sickens me to see the sight of 'red ice' knowing the truth behind this inhumane occurrence. It must stop.
Matt J. Weiss
Aug 21, 2008 12:31 PM
Matt J. Weiss wrote:
I think many of us agree. Its completely incomprehensible to me. I actually was able to helicopter to the ice flats and photograph the harp seals just before the seal hunt in 2006. By far the most endearing animal I have ever encountered.
You must be logged in to comment.
Support Our Sponsors
Newsletter
Travel with us

Featured Photographer



Follow Us

Sponsors